Skip to content

Plurality in Practice: Case File

Framework Rich McDowell, Martin Benedikt Busch
researcher academic
Download →

This case file examines plural voting mechanisms that weight voter preferences based on identity and expertise relationships to reward diverse group consensus, questioning whether such systems reduce powerful voting blocs or merely shift the nature of power concentration. The authors identify a central tension: while plural mechanisms aim to increase plurality, their successful implementation requires substantial top-down calibration that can introduce new biases and remain vulnerable to capture without careful design.

Related resources

Talk

Salon II: ARC Regenerative Communities - 2024 Protocol Symposium

Kaliya Young and 'day' present research into the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) as a case study in regenerative governance, tracing its origins from the 1969 ARPANET through the 1992 governance crisis that shifted power from Vint Cerf's 'kitchen cabinet' IAB to open working groups organized around 'rough consensus and running code.' They map IETF practices—nomcom's randomized leadership selection, open RFC documentation, dispatch meetings, and ritualized in-person gatherings—onto three pattern languages (Group Works, Wise Democracy, and Social Permaculture) to argue that openness, transparency, and voluntariness are structural necessities, not limitations, for sustaining a healthy digital commons.

case-study governance nomcom-random-leadership-selection

Kaliya Young, day

Talk

Salon VI: Fire Protocols & Attention as Autopoietic Space - 2024 Protocol Symposium

Jiordi Rosales and Nathalia Scherer present their Summer of Protocols research on wildfire and prescribed-burn coordination in Sonoma County, California, framing fire management through the lens of autopoiesis—protocols as active matter that let communities regenerate fire knowledge rather than suppress it. They detail a concrete proposal adopted by the Good Fire Alliance to create regional burn coordinators housed under legitimate funded organizations (like Fire Forward), address land-owner bottlenecks, and reposition 'local knowledge keepers' over absentee landowners as fire experts, alongside a pocket logbook artifact for tracking weather and fire-return intervals.

autopoiesis-protocols-as-active-matter case-study fiction

Jiordi Rosales, Nathalia Scherer

Talk

Salon IV: Plurality in Practice - 2024 Protocol Symposium

Rich McDowell and Ben (surname not given) present findings from their Protocol Institute orienteering grant studying plural voting mechanisms, including a real-world CCM (connection-oriented cluster match) experiment run at a crypto mechanism-design conference to allocate research grants. They identify a mathematical flaw in standard CCM where adding multiple identity dimensions breaks the property that the model should converge to quadratic voting when no groupings exist, propose a deduplication fix, and detail practical failures of Pol.is for generating grouping dimensions, including opaque dimension-reduction and missing-value interpolation causing confusion among participants.

case-study connection-oriented-cluster-match-ccm governance

Ben Bush, Rich McDowell

Topics

case-study coordination governance protocols research